Train Smarter, Not Harder: Why Men and Women Need Different Strength and Nutrition Strategies

WORDS: Rick Brennan- Certified Personal Trainer Coach & Sports Nutritionist, Visit: www.rickbrennan.com.au PHOTOGRAPHY Lifestyle Photography: freepik.com

Understanding the Biological Differences for Better Fitness and Health Outcomes.

Have you ever wondered why your gym partner, who eats just as clean and trains just as hard, seems to be progressing at a different rate? It’s not luck. It’s not effort. It could be biology. Men and women are not created equal when it comes to nutrition and strength training, yet most fitness advice still takes a one-size-fits-all approach. The result? Frustration, plateaus, and wasted effort. Understanding these differences isn’t about making excuses; it’s about working smarter, not harder. No one sets out to fail when taking on a new health and fitness routine, but failure is more likely when you apply the wrong strategy. So, let’s explore how to apply the right one.

When it comes to muscle growth, testosterone is the real MVP. Men have up to 15 times more testosterone than women, which means muscle-building happens faster and with heavier loads. More testosterone also means quicker recovery and more explosive power. However, women are not weaker; they just develop strength differently. Women have more slow-twitch muscle fibres, which makes them better at endurance-based strength training. They can handle higher training volume and recover faster between sets, even if they don’t bulk up as quickly. Despite this, women are often told to train like men, lifting heavy, focusing on low reps, and pushing through regardless of how their bodies feel. Meanwhile, men often overlook endurance and mobility, seeing it as secondary to building raw strength.

The differences between men and women also extend to fat loss and storage. Women naturally store more body fat, especially around the hips and thighs, because estrogen makes their bodies prioritise long-term energy reserves for survival and reproductive purposes. Men, on the other hand, store more visceral fat, which sits around the organs and increases the risk of heart disease. However, their higher muscle mass and faster metabolism allow them to burn fat more efficiently. This is why, when a man and a woman go on the same calorie deficit, the man will often see the scale drop twice as fast. Meanwhile, a woman’s body may fight to hold onto fat, especially if calorie intake is too low. Despite this biological reality, diet culture continues to push extreme calorie cuts on women, leading to hormonal imbalances and a slower metabolism.

I have always maintained that muscle is the organ of longevity and strength training should be a priority for both men and women of all ages. Muscle mass impacts far more than just aesthetics; it plays a crucial role in metabolism, strength, and resilience against injury. Men naturally gain muscle mass faster due to higher testosterone levels, so women need to prioritise resistance training and ensure adequate protein intake to maintain muscle as they age. A poorly designed training or nutrition plan doesn’t just lead to plateaus; it can accelerate muscle loss, increase fatigue, and make recovery harder. It is not about working out more, but about training in a way that protects and optimises long-term health.

The role of protein and fats in the diet also varies between men and women. Men generally thrive on high-protein diets, as their testosterone drives muscle protein synthesis. Consuming 1.6 to 2.2 grams of protein per kilogram of body weight can help men build and recover muscle more effectively. Women also benefit from higher protein intake, which supports better body composition. However, women often need healthy fats just as much as protein. Fats are essential for hormone balance, brain function, and metabolism. Cutting fats too low can lead to low energy, hormonal imbalances, and stalled progress. This is why diets like fasting, keto, and aggressive calorie cuts might work short-term for men but often backfire on women. Different bodies need different fuels for optimal performance.

When it comes to stress, recovery, and avoiding burnout, men and women again respond differently. Men’s bodies react to stress by increasing cortisol and testosterone levels, which can temporarily enhance performance. Women, however, often experience a drop in estrogen when stress is high, negatively impacting energy, mood, and metabolism. This is why a man can train hard, eat aggressively, and recover well, while a woman on the same program might feel fatigued, bloated, and hormonally out of balance. Instead of applying the same approach to both genders, training programs should be adapted to these biological differences.

Rick Brennan – Certified Personal Trainer, Coach & Sports Nutritionist. www.rickbrennan.com.au

The reality is that men and women do not just burn fuel differently, they also recover, respond to stress, and adapt to training in unique ways. Yet, most fitness trends ignore this truth. The problem is not that one gender has it easier than the other; the problem is that most people are playing the wrong game. Men should focus on building power and recovery, lifting heavy, prioritising protein intake, but not neglecting endurance or mobility work. Women should embrace strength training that involves higher volume and aligns with their natural cycles, prioritising healthy fats and avoiding overtraining during low-energy periods.

Scan To Be The Best Version of You

Ignoring these differences often leads to burnout, frustration, and the sense that you are “doing everything right” but not seeing results. However, when you start to work with your biology, not against it, that is when real progress happens. Your body is not broken and you are not failing – you might just be following a strategy that does not align with your specific needs. The key question to ask yourself is this: Are you training and eating in a way that suits your body, or are you following a plan designed for someone else entirely?

The path to achieving fitness and nutrition goals is not about working harder, but about smarter strategies. By understanding and respecting the biological differences between men and women, you can create a more effective and enjoyable approach to health and fitness. Embrace a tailored strategy that aligns with your unique physiology, and you will not only see better results but also build a healthier, more resilient body for the long term.

Click here: www.rickbrennan.com.au